Torn

****** THIS CHAPTER TAKES PLACE TWO WEEKS AFTER THE DAY CALLIE WAS DRUNK******

Callie's Point of View--

"THAT'S what you're wearing?" Sara raises an eyebrow, as she slips on white high heels. I nod and shrug. I look down at my black, ripped, skin tight jeans, my black vans, and black t shirt.

"Yeah. What's wrong with it?"

Sara's Point of View--

Calum loves black.

"Well, look at me." I say, referring to my white, skin tight, strapless dress, with a gold zipper going all the way down. "And then look at... You." I shrug.

"Yeah but that whole dress-y look, isn't really my style." She says, as she finishes putting her blue hair in a high ponytail, with her bangs left out.

"But we're going to a party." I frown.

"It's fine, I'm fine." She smiles.

Callie's Point of View--

Sara huffs. "Fine. Let's go."

You'd think keeping the secret of what happened between Calum and I that night would be hard, but it's really not. I mean, Calum and I agreed if we feel a moment, we'd just cut it off. It helps that Michael is in on all of this too, because he all butts in when something is about to happen.

We get to Ashton's house, and walk through the crowd of people. We find our friends circled around the island in the kitchen. I sit on a stool, while everyone greets us. Well, besides Jess. She won't talk to me, which at the moment, I'm okay with. Morgan is sitting on the counter, facing away from us. Michael is in front of her. She wraps her legs around his hips and giggles at something he says while she pulls him closer. Ashton and Jess are talking about something that seems pretty serious, a couple feet away from us.

Sara immediately goes over to Calum, who is staring down her outfit. Ick. She wraps her arms around his waist, and with the hand that isn't holding a beer, he wraps his arm around her back, and kisses her. I look away. Luke is just on his phone, drinking a beer, doing his best to not look at me.

Ashton's Point of View--

"You basically ruined their relationship, Jess." I say with a seriously tone. She rolls her eyes.

"They were going to break up soon anyways. She and Calum DO have something going on." She cross her arms.

"Yeah, maybe. Can you blame them though? They were in love! They showed each other sides on themselves we haven't seen before. Of course they still have leftover feelings, but you are in no position to ruin Callie and Luke's relationship!" I say.

"I just told him what was going on, he had a right to know." She says. I'm about to say something when she cuts me off. "Do you think Callie and Calum should be together?" She frowns.

I shrug. "Well, yeah."

Her eyes widen. "After Calum just dumped her like that? In front of us?"

"He made a bad move, but neither of them have been as happy since. What, do you want Luke and Callie to be together?" I cross my arms.

"Yeah." She shrugs. "He was actually there for her-"

"He dumped her, yelling, infront of the ENTIRE student body!"

"Well Calum destroyed her for a year!"

"Yeah, BECAUSE of how much she loved him!" I protest. She rolls her eyes.

"Look, Luke and Callie are meant to be together, and I'm going to prove it to you."

"Fine." May the best match maker win. I turn to everyone else, "We should play truth or dare."

"Okay but," Jess says, "we should do it in the basement." Shit. My basement is the last place Calum and Callie kissed before he broke up with her. They all nod, and we make our way through the crowd of people. I shut the door, and find everyone already sitting in a circle. Callie is next to Calum! Yes! Although.. So is Sara. Ugh.

I sit in my arm chair. "Michael, truth or dare?"

"Ummm. Dare." He grins.

"I dare you to kiss Sara." I chuckle, but stop when Morgan gets up and grabs me by the shirt. "Okay, okay, sheesh. I dare you to kiss Luke." She lets go of my shirt and just starts laughing like hell. She sits back down next to Mikey.

"Are you gonna do it?" She asks him, grinning. He looks hesitantly from her to Luke. Luke looks absolutely terrified.

"N-No." He says.

"Oh come on, Mike." Callie rolls her eyes.

"Well, is he at least a good kisser?" He asks Callie, and her facial expression changes completely. Her smile fades, and she just stares at Michael, as if to say 'why- why would you ask me that'.

"I... Didn't pick truth." She says quickly, and takes a drink of the beer she somehow got.

"Do it, Mikey." Morgan begs, tugging on his sleeve. He sighs.

"Fiiinne." This isn't even that bad compared to what we normally dare. Michael walks over to the trembling Luke, and pecks him on the lips. Michael walks back to Morgan, and wipes his lips. I guess that turned Morgan on, because right after he sat back down she started making out with him.

"Okay, well since Michael is occupied," Jess smiles, "Callie, truth or dare." She smirks.

Callie's Point of View--

Oh god. It's JESS, she's going to make me do something I REALLY don't want to do. But unless I'm drunk, I've never in my life said truth.

I sigh, "Dare, I guess."

"I dare you to pash with Luke." She grins. I glance at Luke, who's staring at the floor.

"Uh- I- I don't think that's a good idea.." I say, playing with the rubber band on my wrist.

"Are you backing out?" She asks, knowing I never back out of a dare. I bite my lip, and look at Luke. I wanted to tell him somehow it didn't mean anything. He's never played truth or dare with us like this before, so he's probably going to think if I kiss him, I want to. Jess knows that.

"No." I say quietly. I walk over to Luke, and quickly kiss him.

"No no, that wasn't making out." She crosses her arms.

"Jess, don't make her-" Ashton starts.

"No, she said she'd do it." She says, staring me down.

"Fine." I say strongly. I kiss Luke again, sliding my tongue into his mouth, but quickly pull away. "Happy now?"

"Uh huh." She grins. I roll my eyes, and walk back to where I was sitting.

"Uh. Morgan, truth or dare." I say, and she pulls away from Michael.

"Oh-Uh, truth." She smiles, as Michael kisses her neck.

"Have you ever kissed someone while you had something going on with Mikey." I ask.

"Nope." She giggles as Michael starts nipping at her skin.

Mikey's Point of View--

Well, that makes ME feel like a complete douche bag. Of course I kissed other girls, but not while we were dating. We weren't officially anything, so I didn't think it mattered.

Ashton's Point of View--

Morgan giggles some more as Michael gets more rough with her neck, and she waves to me, "You can ask someone, I'm busy." She smiles. She takes hold of Michael's head and starts kissing him normally.

"Uh. Okay then. Calum, truth or dare."

"Dare." He says, assuming it won't be that bad. No, no. If Jess is trying to get Luke and Callie back together, then I'm trying to get Calum and Callie back together.

"I dare you to play too hot with Callie." I say, playing with my fingers. Jess shoots a glare my way, but I ignore it. Michael stops kissing Morgan, and stares at Callie, who is chewing nervously on her lip.

Callie's Point of View--

It's like the whole fucking room is against me! If Calum and I do that, Sara is going to see right through the secret we've been keeping, and then all hell will break loose.

Calum looks at me for confirmation, and I shrug. "We never back out of dares..." I point out. He looks at Sara, who is trying to best to remain calm.

"Yeah." She plasters on her best fake smile, "Why start now."

Sara's Point of View

Unless you have something to hide?

Calum's Point of View

"O-Okay." I stutter. I NEVER stutter. Callie glances at Michael, who looks like he just saw a ghost.

"You know, maybe they shouldn't do this?" Michael says, looking at Ashton.

"Are you cool with it, Calum?" He asks.

"Uh. I-I guess." I say, staring at Callie.

"And Callie?"

"Uhm-"

"See? They're cool with it."

"Let's just get this over with." Callie huffs, and walks over to me. She sits in front of me, and presses her lips up against mine, holding her hands behind her back. My tongue slides into her mouth, and it's almost as if we're trying to prove how much we're over each other. I mean, by kissing. She bites my lip, knowing that's the one thing that drives me absolutely crazy. I don't like it soft, though. I have this really big pain kink, so when she bites down on my lip, I can't help but grab her waist and pull her towards me. She pulls back a little bit. "I win." She says, looking into my eyes. We both remember that it was just a dare and separate, just as Sara leaves the room.

"Damn it." I breathe, and run after her.

Ashton's Point of View--

I smile at Jess, who just rolls her eyes.

"Ash, can I talk to you?" Callie asks, not sounding to happy. I nod. We walk out in the hallway, "Why the fuck would you make us do that when you KNOW I'm not over him?!"

"Jess thought you were meant to be with Luke, so I had to prove to her you're meant to be with Calum." I explain.

"Did you ever think maybe I'm not meant to be with either of them!?" She yells, them storms off into the house. Oops.

Callie's Point of View--

I walk over to the bathroom, where Calum is leaning against the door.

"Babe, please open the door." He says. He sees me, and stands up.

"I could try." I suggest. He nods. "Sara, are you hiding or actually going to the bathroom?" I ask.

"Hiding." She replies.

"Okay." I take a bobby pin out from my pocket and pick the lock. Calum looks at me smiling, but I try to ignore it. I open the door, "That didn't mean anything Sa-"

"I don't want to talk to you." She cross her arms.

"Okay." I walk out into the living room.

Calum's Point of View--

"You SAID there was nothing going on!" She yells.

"There isn't anything!" I yell back.

"There obviously is, Calum! I bet you didn't even REMEMBER it was a game until Callie said she won!"

"Sara, I love YOU!"

"Maybe, but you love her MORE!" She screams. "I tried to ignore it." Her eyes tear up. "I really did, Cal, because I love you, and I thought it would get better, but it's not s-so.. We're over." She says, and walks out.

I'm left standing in the bathroom, completely shocked at what just happened.

Notes